Skip to content

Implement Migration CLI Commands (migrate:generate, migrate:up, migrate:down, migrate:status) #190

@0xvasanth

Description

@0xvasanth

Issue: Implement Migration CLI Commands

Summary

The toasty CLI defines migration commands but they are not implemented. All commands print "TODO: implementation" messages instead of performing the actual migration operations.

Commands Affected

All migration commands are affected:

  • toasty migrate:generate
  • toasty migrate:up
  • toasty migrate:down
  • toasty migrate:status

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Clone the repository
  2. Build the CLI: cargo build --bin toasty
  3. Try to generate a migration:
cargo run --bin toasty -- migrate:generate --message "test" --dir ./migrations

Expected Behavior

The command should:

  1. Create the migrations directory if it doesn't exist
  2. Generate a migration file with up/down SQL
  3. Save a schema snapshot

Actual Behavior

The command outputs:

Generating migration: test
Migration directory: ./migrations
✅ Migration generated (TODO: implementation)

But no files are created and no directory is made.

Source Code

In crates/toasty-cli/src/main.rs, all migration commands have TODO placeholders:

Commands::MigrateGenerate { message, dir } => {
    println!("Generating migration: {}", message);
    println!("Migration directory: {}", dir);

    // TODO: Implement migration generation
    // 1. Load current schema snapshot
    // 2. Build schema from current models
    // 3. Detect changes
    // 4. Generate migration file
    // 5. Save new snapshot

    println!("✅ Migration generated (TODO: implementation)");
    Ok(())
}

Context

I'm testing toasty with a user management system (users, roles, permissions) and would like to use the migration system for schema management instead of db.reset_db() which destroys all data.

The toasty-migrate crate appears to have the infrastructure in place:

  • SchemaSnapshot
  • SchemaDiff
  • MigrationGenerator
  • MigrationRunner
  • MigrationTracker

It just needs to be wired up to the CLI commands.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions